Nottingham Forest player ratings as debutants impress in Carabao Cup defeat to Newcastle

It finished 1-1 at full-time at the City Ground in the second round tie. But Nuno Espirito Santo’s side lost 4-3 on spot-kicks.

With just 18 seconds remaining, the Reds found themselves behind, which was the worst possible start for them. The Magpies jumped ahead early on when rookie custodian Carlos Miguel made an initial save to stop Alexander Isak, but he was unable to stop Joe Willock’s follow-up.
However, Forest gave a favourable response. With the exception of the first minute or so, they played well in the first half and appeared dangerous going forward.

Just before halftime, Taiwo Awoniyi headed a Jota Silva cross over and then headed a Ramon Sosa free kick. As the hosts put pressure on their opponents, both wingers took a shot.

Still, there were moments of nervousness for the Reds in the back. Miguel kept his team in the game by blocking Sandro Tonali and Miguel Almiron in the first half.

Shortly after the restart, the home team scored an equaliser, so those saves were crucial. After Alex Moreno’s throw-in was flicked in, Jota was there to lash the ball in.

Forest persevered in trying to find a winner, but in the end became weary. Miguel had to make an incredible late save to deny Lewis Hall and send the game to penalties.

Neco Williams, Nikola Milenkovic, and Callum Hudson-Odoi all scored from the penalty spot. But Taiwo Awoniyi and Ibrahim Sangare’s misses proved costly. Here is Sarah Clapson, a Reds reporter,’s assessment of the Forest players at the City Ground.

Carlos Miguel Although his defence didn’t do much to help that time, it wasn’t the way he would have wanted his debut to go, giving up so soon. continued to make some impressive saves. Evaluation: 8 out of 10.

Eric Silva Moreira: Forest appears to be holding a true gem. At just eighteen, he is brimming with potential. looked completely at home during his debut for the team. Score: 8.5 out of 10.

Willy Boly: Had the honour of donning the armband, and he made an effort to maintain the team’s composure following the early loss. remains a vital component of the team. Score: 7.5 out of 10.

After the Reds had calmed down, Andrew Omobamidele: Always tried to carry the ball out from the back. Always appeared at ease holding it at his feet. Evaluation: 8 out of 10.

Zachary Abbott: was always going to be difficult entering a significantly altered defence. recovered from a rough beginning and held his own for the most part of the rest of the game. Score: 7 out of 10.

Alex Moreno: By the end, he had truly established himself and had grown into the game. Fantastic throw for the equaliser, and equally passionate celebration of a significant block at the other end. Score: 8.5 out of 10.

Elliott Anderson: Against his old team, he gave it everything he had. displayed a superb passing range and came dangerously close to scoring with a second-half effort. Score: 8.5 out of 10.

Nicolas Dominguez: The Argentinean put on a really spirited display in the middle of the pitch. became entangled and appeared to engulf each grass blade. Score: 8.5 out of 10.

Jota Silva: What a fantastic way to celebrate his first Garibaldi start, showing off his signature goal celebration. a powerful blow that was also well-deserved. Score: 8.5 out of 10.

Taiwo Awoniyi: Maybe he’s still developing his match sharpness, so he’s a little rusty. Even though his penalty was not very good, he is improving and will gain confidence from playing the full ninety minutes. Score: 7 out of 10.

Ramon Sosa: Has the Reds discovered a different set-piece taker? He demonstrated his ability to deliver an incredible free kick prior to the half. A very successful debut. Evaluation: 8 out of 10.

Subs

Nikola Milenkovic (for Abbott, 60 minutes): Came on and immediately settled into the back line. also receives a very cool penalty. Evaluation: 8 out of 10.

Ibrahim Sangare (60 minutes for Jota): a steady presence during his appearance. His penalty struck the bar, which was unfortunate. Score: 7 out of 10.

Neco Williams (68 minutes, for Moreira): buried his indiscretion. There was no lack of poise from the Welshman. Score: 7.5 out of 10.

Callum Hudson-Odoi (in place of Sosa, 68 minutes): Did a great job with his penalty. appeared extremely self-assured as he took the lead. Score: 7.5 out of 10.

Anthony Elanga (in place of Anderson, 78 minutes): Gave the Reds some new legs as they were getting tired towards the end. Score: 7 out of 10.

Turner, Wood, Toffolo, and Perry were not substituted in.

23,083 people were present.